Overview

The Olde Creamery - Mason City stands out as a charming ice cream shop located at 103 E State St, Mason City, IA. This locally owned gem serves up a remarkable variety of ice cream flavors, including fan favorites like River City Cheesecake, Coffee Crunch, and the delightfully nostalgic M&M Ice Cream Cake. For those who appreciate a classic twist, their Cookies and Cream served in a freshly made waffle cone offers a perfect balance of crunch and creaminess.

The experience here goes beyond just ice cream. The Olde Creamery crafts their own waffle cones, bringing an artisanal touch to each serving. Their menu is diverse, catering to all tastes with flavors ranging from Death By Chocolate and Salted Caramel Cheesecake to lighter options like Strawberry and Mint Chip. They also offer sugar-free and dairy-free alternatives, making it an inclusive stop for families and individuals with dietary preferences.

Many visitors praise the homemade quality and unique flavors. For example, the Lemon Pound Cake flavor has been noted as exceptional, and their baked goods—cookies and brownies—add even more variety to the indulgence. Those looking to celebrate special occasions will find their ice cream cakes excellent, especially with advance notice to ensure perfection.

While the shop is praised for its cleanliness and inviting atmosphere, some guests have mentioned the seating could be improved, reflecting a cozy but somewhat limited space. Still, it remains a favorite among locals and travelers alike, from families with young children who appreciate mini-sized servings to ice cream enthusiasts drawn by inventive flavors and quality craftsmanship.

Overall, The Olde Creamery - Mason City offers a memorable ice cream experience rooted in homemade quality and local charm. Whether you're grabbing a quick treat before heading to East Park or celebrating with a custom ice cream cake, it’s a spot worth visiting for anyone in the Mason City area seeking authentic, handcrafted ice cream delights.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Good for solo dining
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy

What Customers Say

JULIE A
Dec 10,2025
4/5
Great ice cream,clean and comfortable,price is a bit high though!
A Parks
Dec 10,2025
4/5
Delicious homemade ice cream in a waffle cone/dish or sugar cone. Lemon pound cake ice cream was amazing. Reasonable pricing and portion. Need better seating options.
Chris VK
Dec 10,2025
5/5
We’re visiting from out of town for the tractor pulls and stopped with our grandkids for ice cream before going to the East Park (an amazing park too!) for a chance to run. My granddaughter said it was the best ice cream she’s ever had! Loved that they had mini sizes for the kids, brownies that were divine and fun original flavors of ice cream . We’ll definitely be back!
Sarah Heinz
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Probably some of the best ice cream I’ve had. A lot of flavor options, as well as sugar free and dairy free. They also have baked cookies and brownies to add to your ice cream or if you want to make a cookie sandwich, and some other simpler toppings, and they do shakes and malts too. They even make their own waffle cones. We have ordered two ice cream cakes on separate occasions for birthdays and they are absolutely delicious! You just need to give them at least a week notice to make it for you. Try them out and support this locally-owned business!
Jeremy B
Dec 10,2025
4/5
Best homemade ice cream in the area hands down. Birtsles needs to step up there game
james petersen
Dec 10,2025
5/5
The Olde Creamery and gift Shoppe Tasty, local creamery and gift shop in the Mason City Brick and Tile building. Reasonably priced and mixed ice cream flavors. Handmade waffle cones. Very clean. Classic styling of the historic Brick and Tile building. Coffee cookie crunch ice cream with a mini cone in a cup. Salted caramel mini con in a cup. Both excellent!
Kimberly “Kat” Kothenbeutel
Dec 10,2025
5/5
I loved the old beautiful building that this is in and the ice cream was delicious. They have gluten free options too!

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 03:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 03:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 03:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 03:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Friday 03:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Sunday 12:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More Ice Cream Shops in Mason City, Iowa, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!